• About us
  • Raising the Bar
  • Raising your Game
  • The Extra G - Geopolitical
  • Risk Matters - Roundtables
  • Leadership Team
  • Events
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Menu

The Risk Coalition

  • About us
  • Raising the Bar
  • Raising your Game
  • The Extra G - Geopolitical
  • Risk Matters - Roundtables
  • Leadership Team
  • Events
  • Blog
  • Contact
pexels-pixabay-48817.jpg

Value preservation - a boardroom imperative

March 09, 2021

Risk professionals fully understand that in business the delivery of sustainable stakeholder value requires a balance between the focus on value creation and the focus on value preservation. This logical duality can be equated to the notion of offense and defense in the sporting context. In theory, most rational businesspeople also intuitively understand these two complementary obligations. In practice, however, there is often a significant boardroom imbalance between the focus on these two imperatives resulting in a value preservation deficit. 

Historically, organisations have explicitly addressed the value creation imperative at a strategic level through their company purpose, vision, mission statement, corporate strategy, and business model. The value preservation imperative however while perhaps sometimes implied has rarely been explicitly addressed in the same manner at a strategic level. Risk professionals can appreciate that this has had a profound impact both on corporate culture and resulting corporate behaviour.

If history teaches us anything it is that corporate boardroom priorities need to be explicit in nature. Company priorities begin at the boardroom and cascade right down through the organisation all the way to the front lines. The difference between explicitly addressing a company’s value creation obligation and implicitly addressing its value preservation obligation is significant and its impact has already been considerable. Consequently, value creation is considered a priority and tends to be at the forefront of people’s minds when making decisions. Value preservation on the other hand is considered less of a priority and is often only addressed as an afterthought rather than part of the initial decision. 

Such an approach unfortunately highlights a certain lack of maturity in an organisation’s decision-making process. Not surprisingly, ongoing corporate failures and seemingly endless corporate scandals continue to highlight and expose a lack of focus on value preservation, often to the detriment of society and our environment.  Given the nature of risk in an increasingly uncertain world, prudence and common sense would suggest that it is imperative that all corporate decisions should give adequate consideration to both value creation and value preservation.  This should apply to all decisions made at strategic, tactical, and operational levels. 

Recent Developments

In a response to this predicament certain progressive governance bodies have in recent times begun to address this elephant in the room. For the first time, these organisations are now explicitly acknowledging the obligation to preserve stakeholder value as a primary purpose and a fiduciary duty.

My new paper Value Preservation Increasingly Acknowledged as Primary Purpose and Fiduciary Duty outlines twelve significant developments which have occurred in recent years as regulators, standard setters, and other governance bodies finally begin to include explicit references to the value preservation imperative. Board members and risk professionals need to be cognisant of how the boardroom obligation to preserve, protect, and defend stakeholder value against value erosion, reduction, and destruction could impact on their organisation.

Sean Lyons is an author, value preservation activist, and corporate defense pioneer. He is the author of the book Corporate Defense and the Value Preservation Imperative.

Tags: Sean Lyons
Prev / Next

Blog

Featured
For noting, but checked by whom?
November 16, 2026
Andreas Ehstand
For noting, but checked by whom?
November 16, 2026
Andreas Ehstand

A key question for any board member, when reviewing the board pack for their next meeting, has always been: what contained in the pack is fact, forecast or judgement?  With board packs now often drafted with the assistance of AI, this question becomes even more pertinent.  Andreas Ehstand explains that board members should also now be asking a further salient question: of the statements in this paper, which did a person actually check?

Read more →
November 16, 2026
Andreas Ehstand
Beyond compliance: what does principled decision-making look like in the boardroom?
November 13, 2026
Roger Steare
Beyond compliance: what does principled decision-making look like in the boardroom?
November 13, 2026
Roger Steare

Good governance is not simply about making the right decision. It is also about being able to demonstrate that the decision was reached in the right way. Roger Steare, considers how do boards make good decisions when the answer is neither obvious nor contained in the rulebook? At the heart of the discussion, he explains, is a framework comprising three complementary "voices": Love, Logic and Law. Love asks who may be helped or harmed by a decision. Logic asks what the facts are, what assumptions are being made and what outcomes are sought. Law asks what the rules require, what promises have been made and whether the outcome is fair.

Read more →
November 13, 2026
Roger Steare
Beyond sight and sound:  why financial services must make deepfake detection a core security layer
November 9, 2026
Ashima Chopra
Beyond sight and sound: why financial services must make deepfake detection a core security layer
November 9, 2026
Ashima Chopra

Today, it is estimated that over 50% of businesses have already encountered deepfake fraud attempts. The frequency of deepfake attacks has exploded with one digital identity attack via deepfake now occurring every five minutes on average. Ashima Chopra explains that financial institutions can safeguard institutional capital, protect customer trust, and ensure that digital transformation does not become an open door for deception by embedding proactive deepfake detection into the core security stack.

Read more →
November 9, 2026
Ashima Chopra
Why the CMA’s new guidance is a wake-up call for risk professionals
October 29, 2026
Tom Barratt, Ewan Willars
Why the CMA’s new guidance is a wake-up call for risk professionals
October 29, 2026
Tom Barratt, Ewan Willars

The Competition and Markets Authority is making it clear that transparency is no longer just a simple matter of legally precise disclosure.  Structural and navigational factors are now equally critical.  This is a challenge for most organisations – how do they now objectively test and report on how the structure of their communications will affect reader’s understanding, do this at scale, and in an auditable and defensible way? Ewan Willars and Tom Barratt discuss what firms need to do.

Read more →
October 29, 2026
Tom Barratt, Ewan Willars
AI: from productivity gains to real strategic advantage
September 30, 2026
Aileen Wallace
AI: from productivity gains to real strategic advantage
September 30, 2026
Aileen Wallace

Many organisations turn to AI to reduce cost, generate productivity gains and make business cheaper.  This approach, however, misses strategic opportunity to develop real competitive advantage.  Aileen Wallace looks at how AI has the potential to change some of the assumptions businesses often make .  The question boards should really be asking, she says, is: what can we now do that we previously thought was uneconomic?

Read more →
September 30, 2026
Aileen Wallace
Online reviews: the emerging risk financial services firms cannot ignore
September 19, 2026
Andrew Winton, Daniel Mohacek
Online reviews: the emerging risk financial services firms cannot ignore
September 19, 2026
Andrew Winton, Daniel Mohacek

Online reviews are much more than a marketing metric for financial services firms – they play a major part in influencing where consumers place their savings, arrange insurance, take out credit and choose financial products.  If that picture is distorted, the consequences for the firm now extend well beyond reputation: this can create a material regulatory and conduct risk.  Under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act, fake reviews and concealed incentivised reviews are banned practices.  Andrew Winton and Daniel Mohacek from TruthEngine explain the resulting risks.

Read more →
September 19, 2026
Andrew Winton, Daniel Mohacek
Boards do not have a risk problem.  They have a decision problem.
July 22, 2026
Boards do not have a risk problem.  They have a decision problem.
July 22, 2026

Boards now receive more risk information than ever.  Dashboards are richer, risk packs are more sophisticated and oversight frameworks are more mature.  Yet the key question is whether this has really improved the quality of board decision making.  In some organisations, more risk information has sharpened oversight.  In others, it has created more caution and more process comfort without making the decision itself any clearer.  The Risk Coalition’s recent Risk Matters roundtable considered the issues around information and decision making.

Read more →
July 22, 2026
AI governance: why boards need to look beneath the surface
June 14, 2026
Pauline Norstrom
AI governance: why boards need to look beneath the surface
June 14, 2026
Pauline Norstrom

When it comes to AI, in the boardroom there is recognition that something material is changing.  But there isn’t always a shared view of where it sits, who owns it or how it should shape decisions.  This gap matters and, with AI, the optics of governance can arrive well before the substance.

Developing frameworks and committees bring structure, provide a common language and signal that an issue is being taken seriously – but AI does not behave like traditional technology.  AI-enabled features appear inside mainstream tools and its capability can span processes, functions and suppliers in ways that are not immediately visible.  In a recent Risk Coalition roundtable, Pauline Norstrom, characterised this as an iceberg problem, and discussed the risks and challenges that all boards need to be aware of.

Read more →
June 14, 2026
Pauline Norstrom
Uncovering a hidden risk - focusing on intelligibility
May 8, 2026
Ewan Willars
Uncovering a hidden risk - focusing on intelligibility
May 8, 2026
Ewan Willars

Across sectors, there is an increasing focus by regulators on consumer understanding, as well as preventing harm and confusion by ensuring that key disclosures are made more intelligible.  At present, the form and format of disclosures prescribed by law and regulation continue to be the dominant influence on how firms communicate, from pre-sales information, terms and conditions, contractual agreements, to post-sales communications.  These rigid disclosure rules often work at odds with the ability of consumers to understand the communications, and we are now seeing regulators focus increasingly on removing prescription to ensure a focus on better outcomes.  Ewan Willars from Amplified Global discusses the changes that are taking place.  

Read more →
May 8, 2026
Ewan Willars
Go to jail.jpg
December 15, 2025
Risk Matters: ECCTA – in the Boardroom
December 15, 2025
Read more →
December 15, 2025
Strengthening risk oversight
October 27, 2025
Hanif Barma
Strengthening risk oversight
October 27, 2025
Hanif Barma

Risk governance is an essential element of decision making by organisations, even more so today in a complex, unpredictable and fast-changing business environment. Risk arrangements at board level can miss the point if they focus only on mitigating downside risk - they are in danger of losing sight of new opportunities that are necessarily grasped to ensure long-term sustainability. Hanif Barma summarises a recent roundtable discussion jointly hosted by Diligent and the Risk Coalition. A major conclusion of the discussion, which involved board members and senior risk professionals, was that a change in mindsets and behaviours was needed to drive effective risk governance.

Read more →
October 27, 2025
Hanif Barma
September 16, 2025
True, Fair... and Future-Proof: Risk Accounting for a New Era
September 16, 2025
Read more →
September 16, 2025
Risk Matters Blog – The Anatomy of a Ransomware Attack
September 16, 2025
Risk Matters Blog – The Anatomy of a Ransomware Attack
September 16, 2025
Read more →
September 16, 2025
The future of ESG: navigating a fragmented landscape
April 15, 2025
Vera Cherepanova
The future of ESG: navigating a fragmented landscape
April 15, 2025
Vera Cherepanova

The business world has long wrestled with the question of purpose beyond profit. But in the era of ESG (Environmental, Social and Governance), this debate has become more than philosophical – it’s a battleground where culture wars, regulatory demands and investor expectations collide. In this Risk Coalition blog, Vera Cherepanova looks ahead and considers the evolution and challenges of the ESG landscape, and discusses how this might evolve in future.

Read more →
April 15, 2025
Vera Cherepanova
Internal audit and risk management must work together to navigate uncertainty
March 6, 2025
Mo Warsame, Gavin Hayes
Internal audit and risk management must work together to navigate uncertainty
March 6, 2025
Mo Warsame, Gavin Hayes

Heightened economic volatility, technological disruption and geopolitical tensions impact all organisations today - whatever their sector. This means that internal audit and risk professionals are under more pressure than ever to help their organisations remain resilient. The Chartered Institute of Internal Auditors (Chartered IIA)’s new Internal Audit Code of Practice - now in force - designed to strengthen internal audit functions and support organisations in tackling these emerging risks head-on, raising the bar for the profession across financial services, private, and third sectors. Mo Warsame from the Chartered IIA explains why internal audit and risk management need to work together to navigate these ever-increasingly challenging risks.

Read more →
March 6, 2025
Mo Warsame, Gavin Hayes